Key insights from the week that was.
The September RBA meeting minutes presented a detailed account of the Board’s deliberations and their assessment of risks. In recent months, the Board has stopped describing its considerations for policy – the choice between remaining on hold and a rate hike – as “finely balanced”. Rather, it has become increasingly clear that the Board view the case for remaining on hold as the “stronger” argument, in step with their growing confidence in navigating a soft landing. While the Board still conclude that “some further tightening in policy may be required should inflation prove more persistent than expected”, the hurdle for the Q3 CPI report or interim Monthly CPI Indicators to raise alarm is high. Westpac remains of the view that the RBA will remain on hold until August 2024 when we see the next rate cutting cycle begin, to restore balance to demand conditions and support growth’s return towards trend.
The Q3 Westpac-ACCI Survey of Industrial Trends demonstrated that the RBA’s rapid tightening cycle is having a material impact on Australian industry. At 51.3, the Westpac-ACCI Actual Composite signals conditions are approaching stall speed. Indeed, that new orders growth held flat for a second consecutive quarter and is now the number one concern of manufacturers is consistent with the marked slowing of the Australian economy. Within this context, firms report there is little incentive to grow their workforce or lift their investment intentions despite an easing in labour and material shortages. Overall, the tone of the survey remains broadly downbeat, with expectations for future activity in the sector subdued – adding to the case for the RBA to remain on hold.
Central bank meetings dominated the news offshore.
The FOMC kept the fed funds rate at 5.375%; however, the dot plot suggests most members expect the data to justify one last hike before the end of the year. During Q&A, Chair Jerome Powell said ‘we need to see more progress’ when speaking to why they felt a further hike could be on the cards. On balance, the FOMC expects the upside surprise to growth currently being experienced in 2023 to persist into 2024, the GDP forecast for next year revised up from 1.1% to 1.5%. The unemployment rate is also only expected to lift at the margin from now to end-2024, from 3.8% to 4.1%, while PCE inflation is expected to only slowly trend down to 2.5% at end-2024. Consequently, the FOMC now expects only 50bps of cuts in 2024 from 5.625% at end-2023.
While they do anticipate a further reduction in inflation and the fed funds rate in 2025 and 2026, it is again expected to be slow going and still leaves the fed funds rate above their longer run estimate of neutral, 2.5%. We see the US economy disappointing the FOMC’s expectations in coming months and so anticipate an earlier and larger start to the cutting cycle, pencilling in 100bps of rate cuts in 2024 versus the FOMC’s 50bps. However, we also perceive greater inflation risks in the out years and so, at 3.375%, our end-2025 fed funds forecast is also materially above the FOMC’s 2.5% ‘longer run’ figure. In our view, these inflation risks are likely to primarily be structural rather than cyclical, limiting the effectiveness of policy and, at the margin, creating greater risk for activity growth and the labour market. Highlighting this, through 2025, we see the unemployment rate holding around 5.0% and GDP growth remaining below trend.
Overnight, the Bank of England paused for the first time since they started hiking in 2021 in a divided vote — five voted to remain on hold, while four voted to hike. The pause came as a surprise to economists, but market pricing had drawn much closer to the final result after the last CPI release. In August, annual inflation growth fell to 6.7%yr as the monthly gain only partially made up for July’s fall, bringing the three-month average to flat. The contribution from services nudged down to 3.2% — just under half of total CPI. Goods also decelerated further, much to the surprise of the BoE. August was the second month that headline CPI undershot the BoE’s forecast of 6.93% for Q3 (July’s print was an undershoot at the second decimal place). Higher fuel costs have been observed in inflation prints in US and Europe, but they did not add as much pressure to the headline print for the UK in monthly terms and were a dampening influence in the annual print. Reports suggest this may be a result of a more delayed response to the spike in oil prices. Overall, the percentage of the CPI basket running above the BoE’s 2% target has trickled down to 81% over July and August.
In addition to the weaker-than-expected CPI, the Committee was concerned about the growth outlook following a 0.5%mth decline in GDP in July. This followed other indicators which suggest weaker growth can be expected in the near term. Strong wages growth had seen economists anticipate further hikes. However, while the Average Weekly Earnings figures continue to overshoot the Bank’s forecasts, they were characterised as “difficult to reconcile with other indicators of pay growth”. The Decision Maker Panel data, frequently referenced by Governor Andrew Bailey, suggests wages growth has been stable at 5%. As such, the Committee will be looking at broader measures of wages ahead.
The statement noted that the current stance was “restrictive” and that “Further tightening in monetary policy would be required if there were evidence of more persistent inflationary pressures”. Before the November meeting, we will get two CPI prints and another wages read which may allay or fuel the hawks’ fears. Hawk Sir Jon Cunliffe will also be leaving and BoE internal Sarah Breeden arriving. Breeden has said she will have a more ‘balanced’ approach to monetary policy.
Across the Tasman, New Zealand’s Q2 GDP rose 0.9%qtr, materially above the market’s and RBNZ’s expectation but in line with our New Zealand team’s view. The technical recession through December and March quarters was also revised away and puts the economy 0.5% larger than the RBNZ expected in August. Given the revisions and Q2 GDP print, we continue to expect the RBNZ to hike once more by year end. The market is also coming to this view, although it is currently priced for this last hike to occur in early-2024.
