ECB’s Lagarde on Inflation: Domestic Drivers Overtake External Sources

    In her address to European Parliament’s Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs, ECB President Christine Lagarde noted that the fall in October’s inflation to 2.9% was due to both “general decline” and “base effects,” with non-energy and non-food inflation continuing to moderate. However, domestic inflation, less affected by imports, remains stubbornly high, indicating inflation is now “driven more by domestic sources than by external sources”.

    Lagarde highlighted that strong wage pressures are mainly a “catch-up” effect from past inflation, rather than a new, s”self-fulfilling dynamic”. She anticipates continuation of the weakening in inflationary pressures, though a slight increase in headline inflation might occur in the near term due to base effects. Yet, she expressed that medium-term inflation outlook is clouded with “considerable uncertainty.”

    Regarding the broader economy, Lagarde pointed out that Eurozone activity has “stagnated” recently and is expected to “remain weak for the rest of the year,” as reflected in Q3 GDP contraction. This weakness stems from higher interest rates, reduced foreign demand, and diminishing effects from economic reopening. While manufacturing output has been declining, services sector is also weakening, and there are signs that job growth may slow down by year-end.

    Despite subdued short-term outlook, Lagarde believes Eurozone economy will “strengthen again over the coming years,” driven by decreasing inflation, improved household incomes, and stronger demand for Euro area exports.

    Finally, she reiterated the ECB’s commitment to maintaining policy rates at “sufficiently restrictive levels for as long as necessary,” basing future decisions on data, inflation dynamics, and the effectiveness of monetary policy transmission.

    Full remarks of ECB Lagarde here.

    BoE’s Bailey: Too soon to have discussion on rate cuts

      In an interview with ChronicleLive, BoE Governor Andrew Bailey pointed out that the recent decline in inflation is largely attributed to the unwinding of last year’s surge in energy prices.

      He highlighted two important phases in the inflation reduction process. He anticipates that by the end of the first quarter next year, inflation may fall to just “under 4%”, leaving an additional 2% reduction to reach the BoE’s target.

      This remaining gap, Bailey noted, is the challenging part, emphasizing that “the second half, from there to two, is hard work.”

      Moreover, Bailey explicitly pushes back against assumptions of imminent interest rate cuts, stating it’s “too soon to have that discussion.”

      BoJ’s Ueda repeats uncertainty on stably achieving inflation target

        In today’s address to the parliament, BoJ Governor Kazuo Ueda provided note that the economy is “recovering moderately,” which is further evidenced by the narrowing of the output gap to “near zero”.

        Ueda also highlighted “We’re seeing some positive signs in wages and inflation”. However, he tempered this optimism by acknowledging the “high uncertainty on whether this cycle will strengthen”

        A key point in Ueda’s commentary was BoJ’s stance on inflation. Despite the positive signs, he stated that the central bank cannot yet assert with confidence that inflation will sustainably and stably achieve its 2% target.

        WTI oil staying near-term bearish, anticipating delayed OPEC+ decisions

          In the current oil market, stability reigns as prices stay in the near-term range, with all eyes on the impending delayed OPEC+ meeting scheduled for Thursday. There’s growing consensus, as per news reports in the past two days, that a compromise on 2024 output levels is within reach. However, it seems the most probable outcome will just be continuation of existing production cuts, rather than any new, drastic changes.

          This outlook, predominantly unaltered barring any unexpected deepening of cuts, steers towards bearish sentiment for oil prices in the near term. A key factor influencing this view is rising inventory levels in US. Concurrently, economic growth in China, a major player in global oil demand, remains tepid. While there have been some positive signs in China, they are not robust enough to shift the demand dynamics significantly.

          Another critical element in this equation is Saudi Arabia’s decision regarding its additional voluntary cut of 1 million barrels per day, which is nearing its expiry at the end of December.

          From a technical standpoint, near term outlook in WTI crude oil stays bearish with 79.98 resistance holds. Current fall from 95.50 if expected to extend through 72.56 to 63.37/66.94 support zone. But strong support would likely be seen to to bring rebound. Overall, range trading should continue for the medium term above 63.67, barring another significant developments.

          US PMI composite unchanged at 50.7, another marginal rise in business activity

            US PMI Manufacturing fell from 50.0 to 49.4 in November. PMI Services rose from 50.6 to 50.8. PMI Composite was unchanged at 50.7.

            Siân Jones, Principal Economist at S&P Global Market Intelligence said:

            “The US private sector remained in expansionary territory in November, as firms signalled another marginal rise in business activity. Moreover, demand conditions – largely driven by the service sector – improved as new orders returned to growth for the first time in four months. The upturn was historically subdued, however, amid challenges securing orders as customers remained concerned about global economic uncertainty, muted demand and high interest rates. Business uncertainty was also heightened among US firms, as expectations regarding the year-ahead outlook slipped to the weakest since July.

            “Businesses cut employment for the first time in almost three-and-a-half years in response to concerns about the outlook. Job shedding has spread beyond the manufacturing sector, as services firms signalled a renewed drop in staff in November as cost savings were sought.

            “On a more positive note, input price inflation softened again, with cost burdens rising at the slowest rate in over three years. The impact of hikes in oil prices appear to be dissipating in the manufacturing sector, where the rate of cost inflation slowed notably. Although ticking up slightly, selling price inflation remained subdued relative to the average over the last three years and was consistent with a rate of increase close to the Fed’s 2% target.”

            Full US PMI release here.

            Canada retail sales rose 0.6% mom in Sep, well above expectations

              Retail sales in Canada rose 0.6% mom to CAD 66.5B in September, much better than expectation of 0.0% mom. Sales were up in four of nine subsectors and were led by increases at motor vehicle and parts dealers.

              Core retail sales—which exclude gasoline stations and fuel vendors and motor vehicle and parts dealers—were down -0.3% mom.

              In volume terms, retail sales increased 0.3% mom.

              Retail sales were up 0.6% in Q3, while in volume terms, retail sales declined 0.5%.

              Advance information suggests that sales rose 0.8% mom in October.

              Full Canada retail sales release here.

              ECB’s Lagarde: We can now observe very attentively

                ECB President Christine Lagarde, said at Bundesbank event today that the central bank has “already done a lot” in fighting inflation, referring to the series of rate hikes. Now, given the “amount of ammunition” being deployed, ECB is positioned to “observe very attentively”.

                With observations on how tightening have impacted people’s economic life, ECB can decide, “how long we have to stay there and what decision we have to make — up or down, she added.

                However, despite these efforts, Lagarde emphasized that “the battle is not over and we’re certainly not declaring victory.”

                German Ifo business climate rose to 87.3, economy stabilizing

                  German Ifo Business Climate rose from 86.9 to 87.3 in November, slightly below expectation of 87.5. But that is still the third consecutive increase. Current Assessment index ticked up from 89.2 to 89.4, matched expectations. Expectations index also rose from 84.8 to 85.2, missed expectation of 85.7.

                  By sector, manufacturing rose from -15.7 to -13.5. Services fell from -1.5 to -2.5. Construction rose from -30.8 to -29.4. Trade rose from -27.3 to -22.2.

                  Ifo said: “The German economy is stabilizing, albeit at a low level.”

                  Full German Ifo business climate release here.

                  BoE’s Pill stresses persistence in inflation fight

                    In a Financial Times interview, BoE Chief Economist Huw Pill emphasized the need for the MPC to avoid prematurely “declaring victory” in the fight against inflation, noting that CPI is still considerably above BoE’s 2% target, currently at 4.6%.

                    Pill acknowledged UK’s economic slowdown, noting “slower growth in activity and employment.” However, he assessed that the current inflation scenario is “more supply-driven rather than demand-driven.” Weakening in economic activity is not necessarily leading to a reduction in inflationary pressures, as might typically be expected.

                    Analyzing recent economic indicators, Pill observed more evidence of “sort of stubborn, high-level rates of inflation” and and growth that are “stronger” than being compatible with 2% inflation over the medium term.

                    He also argued that if the slowdown in economic activities and employment growth is linked to a decline in the economy’s supply performance, rather than a drop in demand, it wouldn’t create the necessary slack to ease domestically generated inflation.

                    Japan’s CPI core rises to 2.9%, above BoJ target for 19th mth, services prices surge

                      Japan’s core CPI, which excludes fresh food prices, rose slightly from 2.8% yoy to 2.9% yoy in October, falling just below expected 3.0% yoy. Notably, this core CPI has stayed above BoJ’s target of 2% for the 19th consecutive month, indicating persistent inflationary pressures.

                      Headline CPI, which includes all items, accelerated from 3.0% yoy to 3.3% yoy. However, core-core CPI, which excludes both food and energy, showed a slight deceleration, dropping from 4.2% yoy to 4.0% yoy. Despite this decrease, core-core CPI has remained above 4.0% for seven consecutive months, highlighting sustained inflation in areas beyond just the volatile items.

                      Breaking down the details, energy prices saw a significant decrease of -8.5% yoy. In contrast, food prices continued to climb, recording a 7.6% yoy increase. Durable goods also experienced a price rise of 3.2% yoy. Notably, services prices surged by 2.1% yoy, marking the fastest gain since 1993. This sharp increase in services prices underscores the broadening of inflationary pressures within the Japanese economy.

                      Japan’s PMIs: Manufacturing contracts, services slightly improve

                        Japan’s PMI for November shows a continuing contraction in the manufacturing sector and a slight improvement in services.

                        Manufacturing PMI dropped from 48.7 to 48.1, falling below the expected 48.8 and marking another month below the crucial 50.0 threshold, which separates contraction from expansion. This ongoing contraction has been the trend since June.

                        Conversely, Services PMI saw a marginal increase, moving up from 51.6 to 51.7, indicating a slight expansion in this sector. However, Composite PMI, which combines both manufacturing and services, edged down from 50.5 to exactly 50.0, highlighting stagnation in overall private sector activity.

                        Usamah Bhatti, an economist at S&P Global Market Intelligence said: “Activity at Japanese private sector firms stagnated midway through the fourth quarter of 2023.” This stagnation is further reflected in the demand conditions, which Bhatti noted remained “muted in November and were little-changed from October.”

                        New Zealand retail sales volume flat in Q3, value up 1.5% qoq

                          In New Zealand, Q3 2023 saw retail sales volumes remain unchanged at 0.0% qoq, defying expectations of a -0.8% decline.

                          However, a contrasting trend emerged in the sales value, which increased by 1.5% qoq, indicating a disparity between the number of goods sold and their monetary value.

                          On an annual basis, there was a -3.4% yoy decrease in sales volume, whereas sales value saw 1.1% yoy increase.

                          These divergences should be reflective of inflationary pressures and corresponding shift in consumer purchasing patterns.

                          Full New Zealand retail sales release here.

                          ECB accounts: All agree to hold, yet open to further hike

                            ECB’s October meeting accounts reveal a consensus among “all members” to maintain the three key ECB interest rates unchanged. This decision reflects a shared confidence that current monetary stance was “sufficiently restrictive” for allowing the governing council to assess the “inflation outlook”, “dynamics of underlying inflation”, and “strength of monetary policy transmission”.

                            The minutes also noted a shift in market expectations, indicating that policy rates are anticipated to remain high for a longer period than previously predicted. Market expectations are transitioning from a “hump-shaped” interest rate path, typically recommended by macroeconomic models, to a “flatter” profile with a delayed first cut in the deposit facility rate.

                            A key point of discussion was the importance of avoiding an unwarranted loosening of financial conditions. In line with this, some members argued for “keeping the door open for a possible further rate hike”, emphasizing the commitment to data-dependence in its decision-making process.

                            In conclusion, ECB emphasized the need to remain “both persistent and vigilant.”

                            Full ECB meeting accounts here.

                            UK PMI composite rose to 50.1, but recession risks and inflation concerns linger

                              UK PMI data for November reflects a significant improvement in economic activity. Manufacturing PMI rose from 44.8 to a six-month high of 46.7, exceeding the anticipated 45.0. Services PMI increased from 49.5 to a four-month high of 50.5, signaling a return to expansion and surpassing expectations of 49.5. Composite PMI, which amalgamates both sectors, also achieved a four-month high at 50.1, up from 48.7.

                              Tim Moore, Economics Director at S&P Global Market Intelligence, observed that the UK economy showed signs of stabilization. He noted, “The service sector arrested a three-month sequence of decline and manufacturers began to report less severe cutbacks to production schedules.” Moore attributed this recovery in part to a halt in interest rate hikes and a decrease in headline inflation rates. However, he cautioned that the data indicates a likely flat trend for GDP in Q4 2023.

                              Despite the uptick in PMI figures, Moore highlighted continuing recession risks. He pointed out that new order volumes decreased for the fifth consecutive month, reflecting limited sales opportunities. Additionally, business activity expectations remained low, close to October’s recent nadir, and significantly weaker compared to earlier in the year.

                              Inflation concerns are also evident, especially in the service sector. Moore mentioned that input cost pressures have risen for the first time in four months, with service providers particularly impacted by the need to pass increased staff costs onto customers.

                              Full UK PMI release here.

                              Eurozone PMI composite rose to 47.1, technical recession ongoing

                                Eurozone’s PMI data for November shows marginal improvement but continues to indicate broader recessionary trends. Manufacturing PMI increased slightly from 43.1 to a six-month high of 43.8, exceeding expectations of 43.4. Similarly, Services PMI rose from 47.8 to 48.2, marginally above the predicted 48.0. Consequently, Composite PMI, which combines both sectors, climbed from 46.5 to 47.1.

                                Cyrus de la Rubia, Chief Economist at Hamburg Commercial Bank, summarized the situation as, “The Eurozone economy is stuck in the mud.” Their nowcast model suggests the likelihood of a second consecutive quarter of GDP contraction, meeting the technical criteria for a recession.

                                Inflation remains a significant issue, particularly in the services sector, where price increases have accelerated due to “astonishingly rapid and even accelerating” rising input costs. De la Rubia attributes these cost increases primarily to higher wages.

                                The employment situation is also expected to worsen. Initially impacting industrial sector jobs, the economic downturn is poised to affect employment in services sector as well. This could lead to an uptick in Eurozone’s unemployment rate, which has so far been relatively stable.

                                Region-specific dynamics show contrasting trends within Eurozone. Germany’s composite index has improved, signaling some positive movement, whereas France continues to show a weakening trend. De la Rubia also points out the challenges faced by Germany, particularly in public investments due to restrictions imposed by the constitutional court’s debt brake, which relegate Germany’s economy “to the back seat in 2024”.

                                Full Eurozone PMI release here.

                                Germany PMI composite rose to 47.1, milder recession but inflation remains high

                                  Germany’s November PMI data indicates a modest improvement in its economic situation, albeit still within recessionary bounds. Manufacturing PMI rose from 40.8 to 42.3, marking a six-month high, and Services PMI increased from 48.2 to 48.7. Composite PMI, climbed from 45.9 to a four-month high of 47.1.

                                  Cyrus de la Rubia, Chief Economist at Hamburg Commercial Bank, noted a cautious optimism about the German economy. He observed, “Despite remaining in recession territory, the rate of slowdown has eased noticeably.”

                                  While, the PMI data aligns with the perspective that Germany entered a recession in the third quarter of this year, the recession’s depth might be less severe than initially anticipated. According to de la Rubia’s nowcasting model, GDP is expected to see -0.7% decline in Q4, an improvement from previous forecasts of -0.9% decline.

                                  Despite these signs of economic easing, inflation remains a significant challenge. De la Rubia pointed out the persistence of inflation, especially in the service sector where input prices surged in November, largely due to increasing wages.

                                  This inflationary pressure is partly transferred to consumers as service sector output prices continue to rise at high rates. The likelihood of sustained inflation is further supported by recent labor market trends, including increased strike activities and significant wage agreements.

                                  Full Germany PMI release here.

                                  France PMI composite falls to 44.5, continued contraction in a dead-end

                                    Recent PMI data for France underscores a deepening economic downturn. Manufacturing PMI dropped to a 42-month low, down from 42.8 to 42.6 in November, while Services PMI exhibited a negligible rise from 45.2 to 45.3. Composite PMI edged down from 44.6 to 44.5, signaling sustained contraction in the economy.

                                    Norman Liebke, Economist at Hamburg Commercial Bank, provided a stark analysis of the situation: “The French economy is kind of in a dead-end.” He observed that for six months straight, output has consistently declined, heavily influenced by reduced demand from both domestic and international markets. Liebke attributed these declines to prevailing geopolitical and economic uncertainties. The economist’s nowcasting indicates a slight contraction in France’s GDP

                                    Furthermore, Liebke forecasts an increase in unemployment in the forthcoming months, marking the first significant employment drop since late 2020. This trend aligns the recent months’ downward trend in employment numbers. Prices continue to rise sharply, as Liebke points out, suggesting that official inflation rates might stay elevated for longer than initially expected.

                                    Full France PMI release here.

                                    Australia PMI composite fell to 27-mth low at 46.4, but no real signs of hard landing

                                      Australia’s manufacturing and services sectors showed continued contraction in November, reaching multi-month lows. PMI Manufacturing index fell from 48.2 to a 42-month low of 47.7, while PMI Services index dropped from 47.9 to a 26-month low of 46.3. PMI Composite also decreased from 47.6 to a 27-month low of 46.4.

                                      Warren Hogan, Chief Economic Advisor at Judo Bank, interpreted these figures as evidence of a further slowdown in Australian economic activity. He commented that the data “all but confirms that the economy is experiencing a soft landing,” aligning with RBA’s expectations. However, Hogan also noted that there are “no real signs of a hard landing” in the survey, indicating a more controlled economic deceleration.

                                      Despite the overall softness in manufacturing, Hogan observed that the sector “does not appear to be slipping into recession” at this stage. Additionally, an improvement in the employment index in the services sector was seen as indicative of “continued strong demand for labour.” This sustained high demand for labour, despite lower activity indexes, points to a persistent imbalance between labour demand and supply.

                                      For RBA, the slowdown in business activity is a welcome development. Still, the strong employment index and an increase in price indexes signal ongoing inflation risks into 2024.

                                      Hogan cautions that it is “still too early to think about rate cuts” in Australia.

                                      Full Australia PMI release here.

                                      BoC’s Macklem: Interest rates may now be restrictive enough

                                        BoC Governor Tiff Macklem, at an event overnight, acknowledged monetary tightening is “working”. He suggested that the existing level of interest rates might be “restrictive enough” to achieve price stability.

                                        Addressing the economic outlook, Macklem anticipates a period of softness in the near future. He noted, and highlighted the dissipation of excess demand that previously facilitated easier price increases in the economy.

                                        Despite this outlook, Macklem reiterated BoC’s willingness to increase rates again if the situation warrants.

                                        Macklem’s comments also came in the wake of the government’s Fall Economic Statement, which he believes aligns with the central bank’s objectives.

                                        He remarked positively on the statement’s implications that the government is “not adding new or additional inflationary pressures,” Macklem said. Furthermore, he appreciated the introduction of new “fiscal guardrails”, considering them beneficial from a monetary policy perspective.

                                        ECB’s Nagel: Close to terminal rate, but nobody knows

                                          Bundesbank President Joachim Nagel, in his remarks at a conference overnight, suggested an element of uncertainty regarding further ECB rate hikes, adding that will be “data driven.”

                                          However, he expressed a belief that ECB is “close to that level we see as the terminal rate,” and added, “rates will stay where they are for a while.”

                                          On a positive note, Nagel observed that inflation is on the decline, describing it as “a greedy beast” that ECB is actively working to tame. He expressed confidence in ECB’s strategy, projecting that it is on track to bring inflation closer to its 2% target over the next 12-15 months.

                                          Despite this optimistic view on inflation, Nagel cautioned that there are still risk factors that could spur another round of inflation. He acknowledged the uncertainty in predicting future economic developments, concluding with “So nobody knows” what’s next.