Gfk: German consumers certainly not assuming recession this year

    German Gfk consumer sentiment for April, dropped slightly to 10.4, down from 10.7 and missed expectation of 10.8. Gfk noted that consumer mood looks “somewhat more balanced” than in previous months. And more importantly, decline in economic expectation halted, “at least temporarily. The index rose 7 pts to 11.2 even though it’s way off last year’s 45.9.

    Consumers are “certainly not assuming that Germany will fall into recession this year”, just a “noticeable cooling off of economic activity”. Gfk k added that this is due to the so called “Five Sages” have lowered lowered their original growth forecast for this year from 1.7 to just 0.8 percent.

    Also, the downturn is more due to foreign than domestic economic factors, including the “lack of decisiveness” regarding Brexit data and nature, as well as US-EU trade conflicts.

    Full release here.

    UK Parliament seized control over Brexit, to vote on alternatives on Wednesday

      The UK Parliament seized control over Brexit from the government after passing a cross-party amendment by 329 to 302 late Monday. The amendment was tabled by former Tory minister Oliver Letwin involving Labour’s Hilary Benn. It gives MPs a series of votes on alternatives to Prime Minister Theresa May’s Brexit deal, including a second referendum, staying the the customs union, no-deal and even revoking article 50.

      Twitter

      By loading the tweet, you agree to Twitter’s privacy policy.
      Learn more

      Load tweet

      Three Conservative ministers resigned from the government to support the amendment, including Foreign Affairs Minister Alistair Burt, Health Minister Steve Brine and Business Minister Richard Harrington. A total of 29 Conservatives rebelled to vote for the amendment.

      The Brexit department issued a quick email statement after the vote. It criticized that the results “upends the balance between our democratic institutions and sets a dangerous, unpredictable precedent for the future.” And it warned that “while it is now up to parliament to set out next steps in respect of this amendment, the government will continue to call for realism – any options considered must be deliverable in negotiations with the EU.

      Earlier in the day before the vote, May declined to commit to abide by the outcome of the indicative votes. She said: “No government could give a blank cheque to commit to an outcome without knowing what it is. So I cannot commit the government to delivering the outcome of any votes held by this house. But I do commit to engaging constructively with this process.”

      BoJ opinions: Downside risks to economy clearly heightening recently

        In the summary of opinions at the March 14/15 monetary policy meeting, BoJ noted that “while uncertainties regarding overseas economies started to become apparent from around last autumn, slowdowns have materialized.”. And, “reflecting these developments, downside risks to Japan’s economy clearly have been heightening recently.”

        Also, it is concerning that developments toward an economic downturn could heighten, depending on developments in overseas economies and the effects of the scheduled consumption tax hike.

        On monetary policy, BoJ maintained that it should “persistently continue with the current monetary policy stance”. But it also emphasized that “in case developments in economic activity and prices undergo a phase shift, it is important to make preemptive policy responses.”

        Full summary of opinions here.

        Canada Freeland: Illegal US 232 steel tariffs should be removed to move ahead with USMCA

          After meeting with US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer in Washington yesterday, Canadian Foreign Minister Chrystia Freeland warned that the US steel tariffs raised serious questions on support for ratification of the new NAFTA, now known as USMCA.

          She said “the existence of these tariffs for many Canadians raises some serious questions about NAFTA ratification”. And, “in order to move ahead with that deal, I think Canadians feel the right thing is, there should be no 232 tariffs or retaliatory tariffs between our two countries.”

          Freeland raised the issue to Lighthizer clearly and emphasized “these tariffs are completely unacceptable to Canada,” repeating the words “illegal,” “unjustified” and “absurd” several times in describing them.

          RBA Ellis: Nexus between labor, households and housing are crucial to economic outlook assessment

            RBA Assistant Governor Luci Ellis said in a speech that the disconnect between “apparently weak national accounts” and “noticeably stronger labor market data” can be traced to the “household sector”. In contrast to the positive picture implied by the labor markets, she noted that “growth in household income has been slow”. Besides, “growth in consumption has weakened recently”.

            While there were talks of “wealth effects” from fall in house prices on spending, Ellis noted that the link is “a bit more subtle than” simply that rise in wealth boost spending directly. At the same time, fundamentally demand for housing rests on the household sector’s confidence and capacity to take on the financial commitments involved in the purchase or rental of a home. Without enough income, and so without a strong labour market, that confidence and capacity would be in doubt.

            Ellis emphasized that “the nexus between labour markets, households and housing are crucial to our assessment of the broader outlook.

            Her full speech here.

            Fed Rosengren: Balance runoff didn’t cause Q4 market turbulence

              Boston Fed President Eric Rosengren defended against claims that Fed’s balance sheet run-off caused financial markets turbulence during last Q4. He said, “concerns about the international economy, potential trade disputes, and a U.S. government shutdown are much more plausible explanations”. Rosengren pointed out that the balance reduction is “still quite gradual”. Meanwhile, equity markets experienced a “substantial recovery” in the first two months this year, even though the runoff was “slightly faster” than in Q4.

              Also, as Fed purchased long-term securities, it encouraged investors to “big up” the price and lower rates on other higher-duration securities. Thus, there was spillover to a wide array of other asset prices. With “quantitative tightening”, Treasury yields and term premia would move higher. But back in December, treasury rate indeed feel and term premium remained quit low. That shouldn’t be the reaction to the balance sheet runoff.

              Looking forward, Rosengren said it’s “unrealistic to expect the Federal Reserve’s balance sheet to return to the size it was before the financial crisis”. Meanwhile, in a hypothetical next recession, central banks will have little room to reduce short-term rates. Thus, there will be increased need to utilize the balance sheet as stimulative tool of monetary policy.

              Full speech here.

              EU completes April 12 no-deal Brexit preparation

                In a statement released today, EU said it completes the preparations for no-deal Brexit on April 12. It also noted that it is “increasingly likely” that UK will leave EU without a deal. EU also urged all EU citizens and businesses to continue informing themselves about the consequences of a possible “no-deal” scenario and to complete their no-deal preparedness.

                EU’s no-deal contingency measures cover PEACE programme, EU budget, fishing rights and compensation, financial services, air connectivity and safety, road connectivity, rail connectivity, ship inspects, re-alignment of the North Sea – Mediterranean core network corridor, climate policy, Erasmus+ programme, social security entitlements and Visa reciprocity.

                EU explained again that in a no-deal scenario, UK will “become a third country” without any transitionary arrangements. And this week “cause significant disruption for citizens and businesses”. In such case, relations between UK and EU will be government by general international public law, including rules of the World Trade Organization. Tariffs will immediately apply at the borders. And these controls could sauce significant delays at the border.

                Full statement here.

                Former Fed chair Yellen: Yield curve inversion signals Fed cut, not recession

                  Former Fed Chair Janet Yellen said in a conference in Hong Kong that yield curve inversion doesn’t indicate recession in the US economy ahead. Rather, the development suggests that Fed might need to cut interest rate.

                  Simply, put she said “my own answer is no, I don’t see it as a signal of recession”. She explained, “in contrast to times past, there’s a tendency now for the yield curve to be very flat”. Thus, it’s now easier for it to invert.

                  On the other hand, Yellen said “it might signal that the Fed would at some point need to cut rates, but it certainly doesn’t signal that this is a set of developments that would necessarily cause a recession.”

                  Into US session: German Ifo helps stabilize sentiments, 10-year bund yield turned positive briefly

                    Entering into US session, the forex markets remain generally in tight range as risk sentiments are stabilized by slightly better than expected German Ifo. Most notably, German 10-year bund yield recovered some ground and turned positive to 0.006 briefly. However, it should be noted that the implications of Ifo data were not much different from last week’s PMIs. That is, manufacturing remains a weak spot in the German economy, with the component declined for the six month in a row. The improvements in headline Business Climate was due to improvements in services, trade and construction.

                    Australian and New Zealand Dollar are the strongest ones for today so far. Sterling is the weakest, await resumption of Brexit debate in the Commons. Yen is the second weakest as risk aversion receded mildly.

                    In Europe, currently:

                    • FTSE is down -0.48%.
                    • DAX is down -0.19%.
                    • CAC is down -0.21%.
                    • German 10-year yield is up 0.0082 at -0.003.

                    Earlier in Asia:

                    • Nikkei dropped -3.01%.
                    • Hong Kong HSI dropped -2.03%.
                    • China Shanghai SSE dropped -1.97%.
                    • Singapore Strait Times dropped -0.91%.
                    • Japan 10-year JGB yield dropped -0.119 to -0.085.

                    Fed Harker: Risks tilt very slightly to the downside, at most one hike this year

                      Philadelphia Fed President Patrick Harker said in a speech in London that “potential risks tilt very slightly to the downside” in the US. Though he emphasized the work “slight” as he saw “outlook as positive” and economy “continues to grow” and is on pace to the the longest economic expansion in history.

                      Harker added there was “continued strength” in the labor market. He’d “cautious against” getting caught up in a single data point in February’s dismal job data. Meanwhile, inflation is running around 2% target and “does not appear to be on a strong upward trajectory”. Rather inflation is “edging slightly downward”.

                      Combining all, Harker stays in “wait-and-see mode”. He expects “at most, on rate hike this year, and one in 2020”. But his stance will be “guided by data”.

                      Harker’s full speech here.

                      German Ifo rose to 99.6, resilient economy except manufacturing

                        Germany Ifo Business Climate improved to 99.6 in March, up from 98.7 and beat expectation of 98.5. That’s also the first increase following six declines in a row. Current Assessment rose 0.2 to 103.8, beat expectation of 102.9. Expectations gauge also rose to 95.6, versus consensus of 94.0.

                        Looking at the details, manufacturing dropped from 9.1 to 6.6, seventh decline in a row. But services rose from 21.3 to 26.0. Trade rose from 4.9 to 8.2. Construction rose from 18.0 to 20.3.

                        Ifo President Clemens Fuest noted “sentiment among German business leaders has improved somewhat”. And “companies are somewhat more satisfied with their current business situation, and they are decidedly more optimistic regarding business in the coming six months.” He added “the German economy is showing resilience.”

                        Ifo economist Klaus Wohlrabe said, “Brexit uncertainty is particularly hitting the industrial sector. The other sectors don’t appear to be affected” .

                        Full release here.

                        Fed Evans: May need to loosen monetary policy if activity softens more than expected

                          More from Chicago Fed President Charles Events. He warned that “at the moment, the risks from the downside scenarios loom larger than those from the upside ones”. And, “if activity softens more than expected or if inflation and inflation expectations run too low, then policy may have to be left on hold — or perhaps even loosened — to provide the appropriate accommodation to obtain our objectives.”

                          On the other hand, “if growth runs close to its potential and inflation builds momentum, then some further rate increases may be appropriate over time to ensure that the economy settles in on its long-run sustainable growth path and that inflation runs symmetrically about our 2 percent target”. He added “in this scenario, the path for rates will depend crucially on any signals of an acceleration in core inflation.”

                          Though, he emphasized that US economy is still in good shape. He pointed to Fed’s forecasts of 1.75-2.0% GDP growth in 2019. Evans said “the lower end of this range is actually in line with my view of the economy’s long-run growth potential. So we’re not looking at a bad number.” Though, “:the economy won’t feel like it is doing very well compared with last year’s very strong performance.”

                          BoJ Harada: Unemployment rate won’t be below 2.5% without QQE

                            BoJ board member Yutaka Harada hailed that the quantitative and qualitative easing (QQE) program boosted productivity and drove down unemployment rate. He said in a speech that “the biggest contribution QQE has made to Japan’s economy was to boost its productivity.” Also, “without QQE, Japan’s jobless rate would not have fallen below 2.5 percent”.

                            Harada is a persistent dissent in BoJ’s monetary policy decisions. He complained regularly that allowing the long-term yields to move upward and downward to some extent was too ambiguous as the guideline for market operations. Also, he urged to introduce forward guidance that would further clarify its relationship with the price stability target.

                            UK to resume Brexit debate as campaigns for second referendum and Bremain gather momentum

                              Brexit debate will resume in the House of Commons today to find a majority for a way forward that breaks the current impasse. Prime Minister Theresa May said she hopes to hold a vote on her deal again this week. But so far, there is no signs the twice-defeated deal could make a turnaround. Instead, May could unveil plans to hold indicative votes.

                              The push for second referendum gained momentum over the weekend with with over a million people joined the “Put It To The People” March in London. Speakers at the rally included Labour’s deputy leader Tom Watson, Scotland’s First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, London Mayor Sadiq Khan. Separately, the “Revoke Article 50 and remain in the EU” petition now gathered over 5.3M signatures.

                              It appears that Chancellor of Exchequer Philip Hammond doesn’t object to a referendum. He said: “I’m not sure there’s a majority in parliament in support of a second referendum… Many people will be strongly opposed to it, but it’s a coherent proposition and it deserves to be considered along with the other proposals.”

                              However, Brexit Minister Stephen Barclay warned that “at its logical conclusion, the risk of a general election increases because you potentially have a situation where parliament is instructing the executive to do something that is counter to what it was elected to do.”

                              Meanwhile, the Sunday Times  reported that 11 unidentified senior ministers could try to oust May today as she has become a toxic and erratic figure whose judgment has “gone haywire”. Two leading candidate Cabinet Minister David Lidington and Environment Secretary Michael Gove backed May though. Also, it’s reported that hardline Brexiteer including Jacob Rees-Mogg & Iain Duncan Smith demanded May to set a timeline to step done for get their support on the Brexit deal.

                              With short Article 50 extension granted by EU last week, if UK parliament could approve a deal, Brexit is delayed to May 22. If no deal is approved, UK will have to leave with no withdrawal agreement on April 12, or provide an alternative.

                              ECB Rehn: Markets too relaxed on Brexit risks

                                ECB Governing Council member Olli Rehn warned that the risks of no-deal Brexit are underestimated by the markets. Talking to Germany’s Die Welt newspaper, he said “in the short term Brexit is surely the biggest threat”. And, “financial markets seem to be too relaxed and appear to underestimate the risk.”

                                On Eurozone economy, Rehn said “growth has indeed slowed down significantly and we must be worried about the economy.”

                                Fed Evans: No rate hike until H2 2020

                                  Chicago Fed President Charles Evans said at a conference in Hong Kong that he now doesn’t expect a rate hike until second half of next year. He noted the US economy is in a strong position. Fed funds rate is seen as close to neutral. And it’s good time to pause and be cautious. Yet, that’s a rather abrupt turn as just back in January, he expected Fed could hike as many as three times this year, assuming the economy remains reasonably strong.

                                  Evans described the inversion of 3-month to 10-year yield curve as “pretty narrow”. But he also noted that there’s be a “secular decline” in long term interest rates. Some of his is “structural” having to do with “lower trend growth, lower real interest rates.” Hence, “in that environment, it’s probably more natural that yield curves are somewhat flatter than they have been historically.”

                                  US PMI manufacturing dropped to 21-month low, gap opening up with services

                                    In March, US PMI manufacturing dropped to 52.5, down from 53.0 and missed expectation of 53.6. That’s the lowest level in 21 months. PMI services dropped to 54.8, down from 56.0 and missed expectation of 55.8. PMI composite dropped to 54.3, down from 55.5. That’s a 6-month low too.

                                    Commenting on the flash PMI data, Chris Williamson, Chief Business Economist at IHS Markit said:

                                    “US businesses reported a softer end to the first quarter, with output growth easing to the second lowest recorded over the last year. The PMI survey data nevertheless remain encouragingly resilient, indicative of the economy growing at an annualised rate in excess of 2% in the first quarter, suggesting some potential upside to many current growth forecasts.

                                    “A gap has opened up between the manufacturing and service sectors, however, with goods-producers and exporters struggling amid a deteriorating external environment and concerns regarding the impact of trade wars. The survey is consistent with the official measure of manufacturing production falling at an increased rate in March and hence acting as a drag on the economy in the first quarter.

                                    “At the moment, the service sector appears to be holding up relatively well. But the worry is that manufacturing woes are spreading to service providers, via reduced demand for services such as transport and storage as well as deteriorating business optimism about the outlook – which fell to the lowest for nearly three years in March – and a cooling of the labour market. The survey showed hiring across both manufacturing and services hit the weakest for just under two years in March.

                                    “Price pressures have meanwhile cooled alongside the slowdown. Input prices – a key leading indicator of inflation trends – rose at the slowest rate for two years.”

                                    Full release here.

                                    Trump said he won’t drop auto tariffs to zero even if EU proposes so

                                      In a Fox Business interview, Trump repeated that EU is treating the US as bad as China in terms of trade. And, asked if he would agree to zero tariffs on autos if the EU proposed so, Trump said “no”. He added, “I would do it for certain products, but I wouldn’t do it for cars.” Trump is again inconsistent with what he said before. Apparently, he’s not that much of a free trade advocate as he proclaimed.

                                      In the G7 summit last June, Trump surprised other leaders and called for dropping all tariffs, trade barriers and subsidies. He said that “Ultimately that’s what you want, you want tariff free, no barriers, and you want no subsides because you have some countries subsidizing industries and that’s not fair”. And, “so you go tariff free, you go barrier free, you go subsidy free, that’s the way you learned at the Wharton School of Finance.”

                                      Economic advisor Larry Kudlow also aid “I don’t know if they were surprised with President Trump’s free trade proclamation, but they certainly listened to it and we had lengthy discussions about that… “As the president said, reduce these barriers, in fact go to zero, zero tariffs, zero non-tariff barriers, zero subsidies, and along the way we’re going to have to clean up the international trading system.”

                                      Canadian retail sales dropped -0.3%, CPI ticked up to 1.5%

                                        Canadian Dollar weakens after weaker than expected retail sales data. Headline sales dropped -0.3% mom in January, below expectation of 0.4% mom. Ex-auto sales rose 0.1% mom, matched consensus.

                                        Headline CPI accelerated to 1.5% yoy, up from 1.4% yoy and beat expectation of 1.4% yoy. CPI core-common slowed to 1.8% yoy, down from 1.9% yoy, matched expectations. CPI core-media was unchanged at 1.8% yoy. CPI core-trim was unchanged at 1.9% yoy.

                                        Into US session: Recession fears intensify, US yield curve inversion, German benchmark yield turns negtaive

                                          Entering into US session, Euro is overwhelmingly the weakest one today after shockingly poor German PMI manufacturing, which dropped to 71-month low at 44.7. Australian Dollar follows closely as second on risk aversion while Canadian is the third weakest.

                                          For the same reasons, Yen is the strongest one for today. Sterling is the second strongest after EU granted UK more weeks to get the Brexit deal through the parliament, until April 12. Dollar is the third weakest.

                                          Development in the bond markets are particularly worth nothing. Firstly, German 10-year bund yield hit at low as -0.01, turned negative for the first time since 2016. Secondly, the most accurate indicator of recession in US, yield curve between 3-month and 10-year, inverts. US 10-year yield is down -0.064 at 2.469 now. 3-month yield is at 2.474.

                                          In Europe:

                                          • FTSE is down -1.32%.
                                          • DAX is down -0.72%.
                                          • CAC is down -1.19%.

                                          Earlier in Asia:

                                          • Nikkei rose 0.09%.
                                          • Hong Kong HSI rose 0.14%.
                                          • Singapore Strait Times dropped -0.05%.
                                          • Japan 10-year JGB yield dropped -0.037 to -0.072.