Fed’s Daly views 2024 as right for rate cuts, timetable uncertain

    San Francisco Fed Bank President Mary Daly, in a Wall Street Journal interview yesterday, suggested that it might be appropriate for policymakers to start considering rate cuts in 2024, especially considering the easing of inflation this year. However, she also cautioned that it is premature to speculate on the exact timing of these rate reductions.

    Daly emphasized the delicate balancing act Fed faces: the need to achieve price stability while minimizing job losses. Fed’s goal is to bring inflation down to its 2% target, but Daly highlighted the importance of doing so gently, “with as few disruptions to the labor market as possible.”

    Another key point from Daly’s interview concerns the real borrowing costs for households and businesses. With inflation showing a downward trend, maintaining the current rate could inadvertently increase these costs. Daly conveyed her wariness that “we could overtighten quite easily, and so that’s what I’m mindful of”.

    Aligning with the broader perspective of Fed policymakers, Daly’s views resonate with the median projections released last week. These projections suggest a majority of the 19 Fed policymakers anticipate a 75 basis-point reduction from the current target range of 5.25%-5.50% for the policy rate, aiming to bring inflation down to about 2.4% by the year’s end.

    Fed’s Mester: The next phase is not when to reduce rates

      In a Financial Times interview, Cleveland Fed President Loretta Mester put emphasis on the duration of maintaining restrictive monetary policy to ensure that inflation reliably returns to the 2% target. That’s contrary to market expectations, which centers on timing and extent of rate cuts.

      Mester’s key statement, “The next phase is not when to reduce rates… It’s about how long do we need monetary policy to remain restrictive in order to be assured that inflation is on that sustainable and timely path back to 2%,”

      “The markets are a little bit ahead. They jumped to the end part, which is ‘We’re going to normalize quickly’, and I don’t see that,” she added.

      When the discussion eventually shifts to the timing and pace of rate cuts, Mester highlighted the importance of one-year forward inflation expectations and their alignment towards the 2% target.

      “If you don’t take action as expected inflation comes down, then you’re really firming policy,” she warned. “You don’t want to inadvertently become more restrictive than you think is appropriate.”

      ECB’s Vasle cautions against premature rate cut expectations

        ECB Governing Council member Bostjan Vasle expressed skepticism about market expectations for imminent interest rate cuts, considering them “premature,” both in terms of timing and the overall scope of such moves. This perspective challenges the market’s anticipation of monetary easing, which currently sees 50-50 chance of a rate cut by March, with a full cut expected by April

        Vasle emphasized that the current market pricing “has lowered the level of restriction”. Additionally, the accommodation priced into by interest rate expectations seems to be at odds with the monetary stance required to steer inflation back to the target.

        Additionally, Vasle indicated that ECB would likely wait until at least the end of Q1 before considering any changes to its stance. This approach is grounded in the need for more comprehensive data, which will only be available around March or April. he added, “We will need to understand the underlying trends better, and we need the new projections, too.”

        On the inflation front, Vasle posited that inflation could rebound at the year’s turn, potentially hovering between 2.5% to 3% through the first half of the next year. Vasle said, “So it’s appropriate to wait and observe price growth through this period and reassess our outlook.”

        Germany’s Ifo business climate dips to 86.4, economy remains weak

          Germany’s Ifo Business Climate fell from 87.3 to 86.4 in December, below expectation of 87.8. Current Assessment index fell from 89.4 to 88.5, below expectation of 89.5. Expectations index fell from 85.2 to 84.3, below expectation of 85.8.

          By sector, manufacturing fell from -13.8 to -17.2. Services rose from -2.5 to -1.7. Trade fell from -22.2 to -26.6. Construction fell from -29.5 to -33.1.

          The Ifo Institute’s statement encapsulates the current sentiment, noting that “companies were less satisfied with their current business” and expressing a more skeptical view of the first half of 2024. The acknowledgment that “the German economy remains weak as the year draws to a close” is telling of the challenges facing Europe’s largest economy.

          Full German Ifo business climate release here.

          NZ BNZ services rises to 51.2, maintains oscillating course

            New Zealand BusinessNZ Performance of Services Index rose from 49.2 to 51.2 in November, crossing the threshold from contraction to expansion. However, it’s crucial to note that this figure remains below the long-term average of 53.5, suggesting that recovery is still in its nascent stages.

            Looking at more details, activity/sales rose from 47.5 to 48.7. Employment rose from 49.5 to 51.0. New orders/business rose from 52.1 to 52.3. Stocks/inventories jumped from 51.5 to 55.0. Supplier deliveries rose from 50.1 to 52.9.

            BusinessNZ Chief Executive Kirk Hope’s observation that the sector has been oscillating between contraction and expansion in recent months underscores the volatility and uncertainty still prevalent in the business environment.

            The proportion of negative comments from businesses decreased from 58.2% in October to 54.0%. This reduction, though modest, is a positive sign, indicating a slight improvement in business sentiment. Hope added, “negative comments continued to be pinpointed on key areas such as the economy, inflation and cost of living”.

            Full NZ BNZ PSI release here.

            New Zealand Westpac consumer confidence rises to 88.9 in Q4, encouraging sign

              New Zealand Westpac Consumer Confidence Index rose notably from 80.2 to 88.9 in Q4, hitting the highest level in nearly two years. Present Conditions Index rose from 69.5 to 77.1. Expected Conditions Index also rose from 87.4 to 96.7.

              However, Westpac noted that the index is still below historical average. This means “many more New Zealanders [are] feeling pessimistic about economic conditions.” But it’s important to recognize the positive trajectory reflected in these recent months. The rise in the Consumer Confidence Index is an “encouraging sign,” as noted by Westpac.

              Full NZ Westpac consumer confidence release here.

              Fed’s Goolsbee: Declaring inflation victory now is premature, akin to counting the chickens

                Appearing in CBS’s Face the Nation on Sunday, Chicago Fed President Austan Goolsbee acknowledged the significant progress made in 2023 but tempered expectations with a note of caution, emphasizing that the fight against inflation is far from over. His stated, “I still caution everyone, it’s not done”. As he also noted, “data is going to drive what’s going to happen to rates,”

                Discussing the scenario of “soft landing” for the economy, Goolsbee expressed caution, deeming it premature to claim victory in this regard. He projected that 2023 would likely witness a significant reduction in inflation, coupled with a stable unemployment rate. Referring to this balance as “the golden path”.

                In his words, Goolsbee conveyed a message of continued vigilance. He cautioned against premature celebration, using the metaphor of “counting the chickens” to emphasize the need for consistent evidence of economic recovery.

                Full transcript of Fed’s Goolsbee’s interview here.

                US PMI composite rises to 51.0, picks up a little momentum

                  US PMI Manufacturing fell from 49.4 to 48.2 in December. PMI Services rose from 50.8 to 51.3. PMI Composite rose from 50.7 to 51.0, a 5-month high.

                  Chris Williamson, Chief Business Economist at S&P Global Market Intelligence said:

                  “The early PMI data indicate that the US economy picked up a little momentum in December, closing off the year with the fastest growth recorded since July.

                  “Looser financial conditions have helped boost demand, business activity and employment in the service sector, and have also helped lift future output expectations higher. However, the increased cost of living and cautious approach to spending by households and businesses means the overall rate of service sector growth remains far short of that witnessed during the travel and leisure revival back in the spring and summer.

                  “Manufacturing meanwhile remains a drag on the economy, with an increased rate of order book decline prompting factories to reduce production, cut back on headcounts and scale back their input buying.

                  “Despite the December upturn, the survey therefore signals only weak GDP growth in the fourth quarter.

                  “The survey’s selling price gauge, which tends to lead changes in consumer price inflation, remains sticky but at a level which is indicative of CPI running only modestly above 2%. Service sector input cost inflation, a key gauge of core inflation, once again remained notably elevated by historical standards, though even here the average rate of increase in the fourth quarter has been the lowest since mid-2020.”

                  Full US PMI release here.

                  ECB Villeroy: Rate hikes are over, but that doesn’t mean a quick cut

                    ECB Governing Council member Francois Villeroy de Galhau, in an Ecorama radio interview, stated, “Barring shocks or surprises, rate hikes are over. However, he emphasized that “doesn’t mean a quick rate cut.” He further clarified, “We are not guided by a calendar, we are guided by data,” and called for “confidence and patience.”

                    Villeroy also commented on the pace of disinflation, noting it is occurring “a little quicker than expected,” largely due to the faster-than-anticipated transmission of monetary policy. He concluded, “In other words, monetary policy is effective.”

                    Madis Muller, another ECB Governing Council member, expressed the view that markets might be “a bit optimistic” about the prospects of early rate cuts. This sentiment was echoed by Robert Holzmann, who stated that there were no discussions about rate cuts among policymakers. Holzmann also mentioned that a majority of the Council members perceive upside risks to inflation.

                    UK services sector boosts PMI composite, averting recession, BoE cut premature

                      UK PMI Manufacturing fell from 47.2 to 46.4, below the expected 47.5. Conversely, PMI Services rose from 50.9 to 52.7, exceeding expectations of 51.0 and reaching a six-month high. This surge in services also lifted PMI Composite from 50.7 to 51.7, marking another six-month high.

                      Chris Williamson, Chief Business Economist at S&P Global Market Intelligence, commented, “The UK economy continues to dodge recession, with growth picking up some momentum at the end of the year to suggest that GDP stagnated over the fourth quarter as a whole.” He added that while employment fell for a fourth consecutive month, the decline was marginal and did not significantly impact unemployment.

                      Williamson also highlighted the dual-speed nature of the UK economy, with manufacturing contracting sharply while services, particularly financial services, showed signs of growth. This growth in services was partly attributed to expectations of lower interest rates in 2024.

                      The divergence between the two sectors is also evident in inflation pressures. While goods-producing sector showed falling prices, service providers reported persistent and elevated inflationary pressures, often linked to wage growth. Williamson indicated that this could keep inflation above 3% in the coming months.

                      He added, “The service sector’s resilience and sticky inflation picture will add to speculation that it’s too early for the Bank of England to be talking about cutting interest rates.” However, he also cautioned that the tentative nature of December’s growth and the impact of looser financial conditions could raise fears of further policy tightening, potentially leading to economic decline.

                      Full UK PMI release here.

                      Eurozone PMI composite fell to 47.0, prolonged economic contraction

                        Eurozone PMI Manufacturing remained unchanged at 44.2 in December, falling short of anticipated 44.5. PMI Services index also declined from 48.7 to 48.1, below expected 49.0. Consequently, PMI Composite index decreased from 47.6 to 47.0.

                        Cyrus de la Rubia, Chief Economist at Hamburg Commercial Bank, provided a critical analysis of these figures. He noted, “Once again, the figures paint a disheartening picture as the Eurozone economy fails to display any distinct signs of recovery. On the contrary, it has contracted for six straight months.”

                        This ongoing contraction underscores the challenges facing the Eurozone economy, with a high likelihood that it has been in a recession since the third quarter.

                        De la Rubia also observed, “A closer look at the top two economies in the Eurozone reveals a positive comparison for Germany in relation to France, particularly within the service sector.” Germany is experiencing a slower contraction in services compared to the more pronounced downturn in France. The manufacturing sector exhibits similar trends, with France facing a faster pace of output decline than Germany.

                        However, De la Rubia cautioned against any sense of satisfaction from Germany’s comparatively better performance, emphasizing, “Obviously, there’s no room for ‘Schadenfreude’ on the German side… the positive comparison does not change the fact that Germany’s economy is in a bad shape, in absolute terms.”

                        Also released, France PMI Manufacturing fell from 42.9 to 42.0 in December, a 43-month low. PMI Services fell from 45.4 to 44.3, a 37-month low. PMI Composite fell from 44.6 to 43.7, also a 37-month low. Germany PMI Manufacutring rose from 42.6 to 43.1, a 7-month. PMI Services fell from 49.6 to 48.4. PMI Composite fell from 47.8 to 46.7.

                        Full Eurozone PMI release here.

                        China’s industrial output Surges, retail sales and investment miss expectations

                          China’s economic data for November 2023 presented a mixed picture, with industrial output exceeding expectations while retail sales and fixed asset investment fell short.

                          Industrial output saw a significant increase of 6.6% yoy, surpassing the expected 5.6% yoy and marking the strongest expansion since February 2022.

                          However, retail sales, rose by 10.1% yoy, which was below the anticipated 12.5%. It’s important to note that this increase was influenced by a low base effect from the previous year, when China’s stringent coronavirus pandemic control measures significantly impacted consumer activities.

                          Fixed asset investment, a key driver of economic growth, increased by 2.9% ytd yoy, slightly missing the expected 3.0%.

                          National Bureau of Statistics of China commented on the overall economic situation, stating: “There are still a lot of external instabilities and uncertainties, and the domestic demand appears insufficient.” The NBS emphasized the need to solidify the foundation of the economy’s recovery.

                          Japan’s PMI Composite up to 50.4, expansion resumes with inflation resurgence

                            Japan’s PMI data for December presents a mixed picture of the country’s economic The PMI Manufacturing index fell to 47.7 from 48.3, underperforming the market expectation of 48.2 and indicating contraction in the sector. In contrast, PMI Services index rose from 50.8 to 52.0. Consequently, PMI Composite index, moved back into expansion territory, rising from 49.6 to 50.4.

                            Annabel Fiddes, Economics Associate Director at S&P Global Market Intelligence, noted, “The December PMI surveys indicate that Japan’s private sector experienced a renewed, albeit mild increase in overall business activity as the year came to a close.”

                            Fiddes further elaborated, “The overall performance of the private sector remained subdued.” This is evident in the composite new business, which declined for the second consecutive month. Although there was modest sales growth in the service sector, it was not sufficient to offset the sharp and accelerated drop in manufacturing orders.

                            Another critical aspect highlighted in the PMI report is the resurgence of inflationary pressures. Fiddes noted, “The latest survey also indicated a renewed pick up in inflationary pressures amid reports that a weaker exchange rate and higher labor and raw material costs had pushed up expenses.” As a result, the prices charged by Japanese firms increased at the fastest pace since August.

                            Full Japan PMI release here.

                            Australia PMI composite climbs to 47.4, aligning with soft landing scenario

                              Australia’s manufacturing and service sectors showed marginal improvements in December, as indicated by the latest PMI data. PMI Manufacturing index inched up slightly from 47.7 to 47.8, while PMI Services index rose from 46.0 to 47.6. PMI Composite, which combines both manufacturing and services, also increased from 46.2 to 47.4. Despite these increases, all indices remained below 50.0 threshold that separates expansion from contraction, suggesting that both sectors are still facing challenges.

                              Warren Hogan, Chief Economic Advisor at Judo Bank, noted: “For the RBA and Treasury, these results are consistent with the soft landing view of the economic outlook. There are few signs that the economy is likely to tip into a steeper downturn next year.”

                              Hogan also emphasized the importance of the employment sector in this context: “Most importantly, the strong employment results suggest the economy may prove resilient in 2024. It is hard to see a sharp downturn in the economy while employment and incomes are expanding.”

                              Full Australia PMI release here.

                              NZ BNZ manufacturing improves to 46.7, ninth month in contraction

                                New Zealand’s manufacturing sector experienced a slight improvement in November, as indicated by the BusinessNZ Performance of Manufacturing Index. The index rose from 42.9 to 46.7, marking its highest level since June. However, it’s important to note that the PMI remained in contraction territory (below 50) for the ninth consecutive month.

                                Breaking down the index, several components witnessed modest improvements. Production increased from 41.6 to 43.6, employment from 43.8 to 47.9, new orders from 44.5 to 47.7, finished stocks from 45.8 to 50.7, and deliveries from 43.3 to 48.0. Despite these gains, the improvements were not strong enough to push the overall PMI into the expansion zone.

                                The proportion of negative comments from the manufacturing sector was 58.7%, a decrease from 65.1% in October and 68.8% in September. This indicates a slight shift in sentiment, although a significant portion of feedback remains pessimistic. The predominant concerns cited by manufacturers revolved around a general lack of demand and sales, highlighting the primary challenges facing the industry.

                                BNZ Senior Economist, Craig Ebert, particularly focused on the production index. He noted that despite a slight improvement in November, the production index remained almost 10 points below its long-term average. Ebert emphasized that “That’s a big undershoot, in historical context”.

                                Full NZ BNZ PMI release here.

                                ECB Lagarde press conference live stream

                                  YouTube

                                  By loading the video, you agree to YouTube’s privacy policy.
                                  Learn more

                                  Load video

                                  US initial jobless claims falls to 202k, vs exp 221k

                                    US initial jobless claims fell -19k to 202k in the week ending December 9, below expectation of 221k. Four-week moving average of initial claims fell -7.75k to 213k.

                                    Continuing claims rose 20k to 1876k in the week ending December 2. Four-week moving average of continuing claims rose 3.5k to 1875k, highest since December 11, 2021.

                                    Full US jobless claims release here.

                                    US retail sales rises 0.3% mom in Nov, ex-auto sales up 0.2% mom

                                      US retail sales rose 0.3% mom to USD 705.7B in November, better than expectation of -0.1% mom decline. Ex-auto sales rose 0.2% mom to USD 571.2B, above expectation of -0.1% mom. Ex-gasoline sales rose 0.6% mom to USD 651.2B. Ex-auto, gasoline sales rose 0.6% mom to USD 516.7B.

                                      For the 12 months period, retail sales was up 4.1% yoy. Total sales for September through November period were up 3.4% yoy.

                                      Full US retail sales release here.

                                      ECB maintains interest rates, lowers inflation forecasts

                                        ECB kept interest rates unchanged, maintaining the main refinancing rate at 4.50% and the deposit rate at 4.00%, as was widely anticipated. In a significant update, ECB substantially lowered its headline inflation forecast for 2024 from 3.2% to 2.7%. Additionally, core inflation forecasts for 2024 were slightly revised downward from 2.9% to 2.7%.

                                        The new economic forecasts paint a picture of moderating inflation and subdued growth in the coming years. Headline inflation is expected to average 5.4% in 2023, then decrease to 2.7% in 2024, 2.1% in 2025, and 1.9% in 2026. These projections mark a notable adjustment from the September forecasts, which anticipated 5.6% in 2023 and 3.2% in 2024.

                                        Core inflation is also expected to follow a similar downward trajectory, averaging 5.0% in 2023, 2.7% in 2024, 2.3% in 2025, and 2.1% in 2026, comparing to previous forecasts of 5.1% in 2023, 2.9% in 2024, and 2.2% in 2025

                                        On the growth front, ECB’s projections indicate modest economic performance, with growth averaging 0.6% for 2023, 0.8% for 2024, and 1.5% for both 2025 and 2026. These figures represent a downward revision from September forecasts, which predicted 0.7% growth in 2023 and 1.0% in 2024, but 2025 was unchanged at 1.5%.

                                        The central bank reiterated that the current interest rates are positioned to substantially contribute to bringing inflation back to its target, provided they are “maintained for a sufficiently long duration.” The ECB plans to continue following a “data-dependent approach” to determine the “level and duration” of policy restrictions.

                                        Full ECB statement here.

                                        BoE stands pat, three hawks vote for another hike

                                          BoE kept Bank Rate unchanged at 5.25%, aligning with market expectations. The decision was not unanimous, with a 6-3 vote where Megan Greene, Jonathan Haskel, and Catherine Mann favored a 25 bps hike to 5.50%. This split decision reflects that the hawks remained persistent in their push more tighter monetary policy.

                                          The central bank reiterated its stance that "monetary policy is likely to need to be restrictive for an extended period of time." This suggests continued cautious approach towards easing monetary conditions, likely due to persistent inflationary pressures. The Bank further emphasized that "Further tightening in monetary policy would be required if there were evidence of more persistent inflationary pressures," indicating readiness to adjust policy should inflation not moderate as expected.

                                          Regarding inflation, BoE forecasts that CPI inflation rate will hover near its current rate around the turn of the year, before gradually declining thereafter. On the growth front, BoE anticipates that GDP growth will be "broadly flat in Q4 and over the coming quarters."

                                          Full BoE statement here.